Business structure

Sole proprietor, LLC, partnership, S-corp, or C-corp?

The right answer changes as your profit, your risk, and your partners change. Here's what each structure actually does — and what it costs you.

20% off when you mention the website referral when you book.

Our recommendation for profitable businesses

If your business is making real money, an S-corp is usually the biggest lever you have.

Not for everyone, and not at every stage — but for an owner-operated business with steady profit, the payroll-tax split is frequently the largest single saving available, year after year, with no new customers required.

Only your salary carries payroll tax

A sole proprietor pays self-employment tax on every dollar of profit. An S-corp owner pays it on reasonable wages — the rest passes through as distribution, untouched by Social Security and Medicare.

The saving grows with profit

At $60,000 of profit the margin is thin. At $150,000 or $250,000, the same structure can keep five figures a year in the business. That's why the profitable ones are the ones who should be looking.

Pass-through, not double taxation

Like a partnership, an S-corp pays no federal income tax of its own. Profit lands on your personal return once — a C corporation's profit can be taxed twice by the time you take it out.

It opens the planning doors

Owner W-2 wages make retirement contributions, health insurance, and HSA planning work properly — and they give lenders and buyers a compensation history to underwrite.

What it honestly costs

  • ·Payroll has to run for the owner, every pay period, with the 941s and W-2s that come with it
  • ·A separate 1120-S and K-1 return each year
  • ·Reasonable compensation must be defensible, not just convenient
  • ·The election is due by March 15 to count for that calendar year — miss it and you wait a year

Payroll and the extra return typically run a few thousand dollars a year. The question is never "is it complicated?" — it's whether the saving is larger than the cost. At a healthy profit, it usually is.

Run your own numbers

Schedule C

$21,194

payroll tax on all profit

S-corp

$12,240

payroll tax on wages only

Estimated annual saving

$8,954

That's $746 a month kept out of payroll tax.

Estimate only: payroll taxes at current rates, before payroll and 1120-S preparation costs, before the qualified business income interaction, and before state taxes. We model all of it in the appointment.

Have us model it exactly

Ready to find out what the election is worth to you?

Bring last year's return and your bookkeeping. We'll price the S-corp against your current structure, including what payroll and the 1120-S would cost — and tell you if the answer is "not yet."

Book the $250 consultation
S-corp, line by line

The same business, with and without the election

An S-corp election doesn't change your company — it changes how the profit is taxed. Here is exactly what moves, and what stays put.

LLC, default treatmentLLC with an S-corp election
Who pays tax on the profitYou, on Schedule C with your personal returnYou, on the K-1 from the 1120-S
Social Security and Medicare15.3% self-employment tax on every dollar of net profitOnly on reasonable W-2 wages — not on the distributions
PayrollNone requiredRequired for the working owner, from the first payday
Extra annual returnNoneForm 1120-S, plus W-2s, 941s, and K-1s
Reasonable compensationNot applicableMust be defensible against your role and the profit
Liability protectionFrom the LLCFrom the LLC — unchanged
Eligibility limitsNone100 or fewer shareholders, one class of stock, eligible owners only
Deadline to elect—Form 2553 by March 15 to count for that tax year
Cost to keep it runningState annual report onlyPayroll, the extra return, and the bookkeeping to support them
When it is the right answerProfit is still modest, uneven, or fully needed in the householdNet profit sits comfortably above a defensible salary

The arithmetic behind it: about 15.3% of (profit minus reasonable salary) is what the election can save, measured against what payroll and the extra return cost to run. General information, not tax advice — the numbers depend on your state, your profit, and your compensation.

What the election doesn't touch

  • The entity itself — you elect a tax treatment, you don't form a new company
  • Your liability shield under the LLC
  • Who owns what, and the operating agreement
  • The business bank account and how clients pay you

When we tell owners to wait

  • Net profit is under roughly $60,000 — payroll and the 1120-S can cost more than the tax saved
  • Profit swings hard from year to year, or losses are still common
  • The owner would have to take wages so low that reasonable compensation becomes a fight
  • The business is a partnership of several owners who each want a different split

Waiting is not a loss. The election can be made in any later year, and making it a year too early costs real money in payroll for a saving that isn't there yet.

The five structures

What each one is, in plain terms

Two questions decide most of it: who is exposed if something goes wrong, and how the profit gets taxed on the way to your personal return.

Sole Proprietor

You and the business are the same taxpayer.

01

Best for: Getting started, part-time work, and low-risk work with no employees.

How it's taxed

Reported on Schedule C with your personal return. Net profit is subject to self-employment tax.

Helps when

  • No formation paperwork or state filing fee
  • Simplest records, cheapest to run
  • Full control, no separate tax return
  • Business losses offset other income

Watch-outs

  • Personal assets are exposed to business debts and claims
  • Nothing separating business and personal banking except your own discipline
  • Harder to land larger contracts that expect an entity name

Choose it when

  • · You're testing an idea or working part-time
  • · Revenue is modest and risk is low
  • · You have no employees and no significant contracts
Liability: None — your personal assets stand behind the business.Annual filings: Schedule C and Schedule SE with your 1040

Single-Member LLC

The liability shield, without a separate tax return.

02

Best for: Owners who want separation from the business but aren't ready for payroll.

How it's taxed

Disregarded by default — it files like a sole proprietor on Schedule C. It can elect S-corp status later without forming a new entity.

Helps when

  • Liability separation without a separate federal return
  • Business bank account and contracts in the company name
  • Keeps the door open to an S-corp election later
  • Credible to clients, landlords, and lenders

Watch-outs

  • State filing and annual report fees
  • Profits still carry self-employment tax
  • The shield can be lost by commingling funds or signing personal guarantees

Choose it when

  • · Revenue is steady enough to justify annual fees
  • · You're signing leases, client contracts, or hiring
  • · You want protection but payroll still costs more than it saves
Liability: Generally separates your personal assets from business debts, when the entity is respected.Annual filings: State formation and annual report, plus Schedule C

Partnership / Multi-Member LLC

Two or more owners, taxed once at the individual level.

03

Best for: Two or more people contributing money, work, or both.

How it's taxed

Files Form 1065 and issues a K-1 to each owner. Income flows onto your individual returns — the entity itself pays no federal income tax.

Helps when

  • Combines capital and skills without an entity-level tax
  • Allocations can be split differently than ownership, with a written agreement
  • Pass-through losses available to owners within basis limits

Watch-outs

  • A partnership return and K-1s every year
  • Requires a written operating agreement — this is where most disputes start
  • Partners generally owe self-employment tax on their share of active income
  • In a general partnership, each partner can bind and be liable for the others

Choose it when

  • · Two or more owners are contributing capital, labor, or both
  • · You're forming a professional practice together
  • · You want flexible profit splits, documented in an agreement
Liability: An LLC taxed as a partnership shields members; a general partnership does not.Annual filings: Form 1065 with K-1s, plus state annual report

S Corporation

Pass-through tax treatment, with payroll for the owners.

04

Best for: Profitable owner-operated businesses where the payroll-tax savings beat the added cost.

How it's taxed

A pass-through: Form 1120-S and K-1s, but owners who work in the business must be paid reasonable wages through payroll. Only the remaining profit avoids payroll tax.

Helps when

  • Profit above reasonable compensation avoids self-employment tax
  • Owner wages create a clean, auditable compensation record
  • Often the largest single tax saving available to a profitable small business

Watch-outs

  • Payroll is required, with real ongoing cost and filing obligations
  • Underpaying the owner invites a reasonable-compensation challenge
  • Strict eligibility: limited to 100 shareholders, one class of stock, and eligible owners
  • Must elect by March 15 to be effective for that calendar year

Choose it when

  • · Net profit is consistently strong enough that payroll cost is clearly outpaced by the tax saved
  • · You're already comfortable running payroll or having us run it
  • · You want the saving without giving up pass-through treatment
Liability: Limited liability through the underlying corporation or LLC.Annual filings: Form 1120-S, W-2s, quarterly 941s, state payroll reports

C Corporation

Its own taxpayer — built for capital and equity.

05

Best for: Businesses raising outside money, issuing equity, or retaining earnings to grow.

How it's taxed

Pays its own 21% federal income tax. Dividends paid to shareholders are taxed again, which is the double taxation people mean.

Helps when

  • Clean structure for investors, priced rounds, and stock options
  • Qualified small business stock can exclude gain on a sale under §1202
  • Richer tax-advantaged fringe benefits for owner-employees
  • Earnings can be retained and reinvested at corporate rates

Watch-outs

  • Double taxation on profits taken out as dividends
  • The heaviest compliance load: formal minutes, stock records, separate filings
  • Losses stay inside the company and don't offset your personal income

Choose it when

  • · You plan to raise outside capital or issue equity
  • · You're building toward a sale where §1202 may matter
  • · You're reinvesting profit rather than distributing it
Liability: Limited liability for shareholders.Annual filings: Form 1120, state franchise or income filings, formal corporate records
Not sure which fits?

Answer three questions

A starting point, not a verdict. Your actual numbers and your state are what settle it.

How many owners will there be?

How much profit do you expect to keep?

What matters most right now?

0 of 3 answered · compare all 5 structures below

Side by side

The whole comparison on one screen

StructureTaxed asPersonal liabilityOngoing effortTypical fit
Sole ProprietorSchedule C, self-employment taxExposedNoneGetting started, part-time work, and low-risk work with no employees.
Single-Member LLCDisregarded — Schedule C by defaultLimitedLowOwners who want separation from the business but aren't ready for payroll.
Partnership / Multi-Member LLCForm 1065, K-1s to ownersShielded if an LLCModerateTwo or more people contributing money, work, or both.
S CorporationForm 1120-S, owner wages requiredLimitedModerate to highProfitable owner-operated businesses where the payroll-tax savings beat the added cost.
C CorporationForm 1120, entity pays 21%LimitedHighBusinesses raising outside money, issuing equity, or retaining earnings to grow.

General information, not legal advice. Structure choice depends on your liability exposure, state, ownership, and where the profit is going — which is what the consultation is for.

How businesses usually move between them

Most owners start as a sole proprietor, form an LLC when the risk or the contracts justify it, and elect S-corp status once profit is steady enough that payroll pays for itself. A C corporation usually enters the picture when outside investors or equity compensation arrive. Each step has a deadline attached, and an election made late can cost a full year of savings.

Read our updates on entity and tax changes
We do the whole thing

From the filing to the K-1, in one office

You don't have to assemble a lawyer, a payroll provider, and an accountant to get this done. It happens here, and the same people who set it up are the ones who file it.

Formation

We file the entity with the state, obtain the EIN, and get the business bank account paperwork in order.

The tax election

An S-corp election is Form 2553, and the deadline is unforgiving — March 15 for that calendar year. We handle the election and the state pieces that go with it.

Payroll

If an S-corp election makes sense, payroll has to run for the owner, from the first payday. We set it up and run it.

The filings after

1120-S, 1065, Schedule C, W-2s, K-1s, quarterly estimates — filed on time, with the books that support them.

Partners and ownership

Operating agreements, ownership splits, and the K-1s that follow. When a dispute needs an attorney, we work alongside yours.

Book an appointment

Business structure consultation — $250

One working session on your business, your profit, and your plans. You leave knowing which structure fits, what it costs you in tax, and what it takes to set it up.

Website referral: 20% off. Mention the website when you book and the fee is $200 instead of $250.

The fee covers the consultation. State filing fees, formation filings, and payroll setup are quoted separately, after we've agreed on the structure.

What the appointment includes

  • A working session on your actual numbers, not a brochure
  • A side-by-side projection of what each structure would cost you in tax
  • A written recommendation with the reasoning behind it
  • The formation, election, and payroll steps required to get there

Not ready for an appointment yet?

Send us a question through the contact form, or ask about bookkeeping and payroll while you're at it. We'll tell you honestly whether a structure change would save you anything this year.

Get a Quote